Compare CAA Insurance insurance in Ontario

CAA Insurance in Ontario: an honest overview

CAA Insurance offers auto and home insurance, often with benefits for CAA members.

CAA Insurance mainly sells its policies directly — online, by phone or through its own advisors or agents. Independent brokers generally cannot place a CAA Insurance policy. What a broker can do is show you prices from other insurers, so you have something fair to compare against the quote CAA Insurance gives you.

Every insurer prices risk differently. Two neighbours with similar cars can receive very different prices from the same company, because insurers weigh driving history, claims, location, vehicle and coverage choices in their own way. That is why comparing more than one option is usually worth the few minutes it takes.

Auto insurance with CAA Insurance

Every auto policy in Ontario is built on the standard Ontario Automobile Policy (OAP 1). The mandatory parts are the same no matter which insurer you choose; the differences are in price, optional coverage, discounts and service.

Mandatory coverage in Ontario includes:

• Third-party liability (minimum $200,000; many drivers choose $1 or $2 million)
• Statutory Accident Benefits for injuries, regardless of fault
• Direct Compensation – Property Damage (DCPD)
• Uninsured automobile coverage
• Optional: collision, comprehensive, and endorsements such as OPCF 20 (loss of use / rental car), OPCF 27 (non-owned auto) and OPCF 43 (waiver of depreciation on newer vehicles)

Home, condo and tenant insurance with CAA Insurance

Property policies are less standardized than auto, so reading the wording matters. A homeowner's policy normally covers the building, your belongings, additional living expenses if you must move out during repairs, and personal liability. Condo policies focus on your unit improvements and contents, and tenant policies cover belongings and liability.

In Ontario, water damage is one of the most common claim types. Sewer backup and overland water are often optional add-ons, so ask whether they are included and what limits apply. Older roofs, knob-and-tube wiring, oil tanks and wood stoves can also affect eligibility and price with any insurer.

Discounts worth asking about

Discount names and amounts differ by insurer and change over time, so treat this as a checklist rather than a promise. Ask CAA Insurance which of these apply to you:

• Winter tires (Ontario insurers are required to offer a winter tire discount)
• Multi-vehicle
• Usage-based or telematics programs, where offered
• Claims-free and conviction-free history
• Monitored alarm, water-leak sensors or sump pump with backup
• Updated roof, plumbing and electrical
• Higher deductible
• Bundling more than one policy with the same insurer
• Paying annually instead of monthly

Buying from CAA Insurance directly vs. using a broker

Buying directly from CAA Insurance can be convenient if you already know you want that company. The trade-off is that you only see one company's price. A broker works the other way: they can't sell CAA Insurance, but they can show you several other insurers in one conversation.

A simple approach many people use: get your CAA Insurance quote, then compare it with what a licensed broker finds. Choose the coverage that fits you best — not just the lowest number.

How to switch insurers without a gap

Switching is usually simple if you plan a little ahead:

• Start comparing 30–45 days before your renewal date
• Have your licence, vehicle details (or home details) and current policy ready
• Ask your current insurer for your claims history (a 'letter of experience')
• Set the new policy to start before you cancel the old one, so you're never uninsured
• Mid-term cancellations may involve a short-rate fee — ask before you cancel